If you're a fan of pizza, Al's Pizza in Sidney, OH, is a must-visit. This charming spot has garnered praise from locals and visitors alike for its incredible selection of pizzas, including standouts like the deluxe and the BLT. Customers rave about the quality of ingredients, noting the perfect balance of cheese and rich tomato sauce, seasoned just right. The restaurant's warm atmosphere is heightened by the presence of owner Tom Martin, who engages with diners, creating a welcoming experience for all.
Service shines at Al's Pizza as well. Reviews highlight friendly and attentive staff who ensure that every guest feels valued. Whether you're dining in or enjoying a buffet selection, the culinary delights — including the popular Peanut Butter Smores pizza for dessert — leave a lasting impression. Patrons appreciate the attentive service and the ability to customize their choices, making dining here feel personal and satisfying.
With its delicious menu, community-oriented vibe, and dedicated service, Al's Pizza has solidified its reputation as a top pizza destination in the Dayton area. Don't miss out on the delightful flavor combinations and the warm hospitality; this eatery is well worth the drive.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Offers delivery
Has drive-through
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Highlights
Has fast service
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves alcohol
Has all you can eat
Serves beer
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Serves late-night food
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Serves dessert
Has seating
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Quiet
Crowd
Good for groups
Popular with tourists
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs available
Has kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Photos
Reviews For Al's Pizza
Bailey Keener
Jun 19,2025
Loved the food! Pizza is great! Love the cheese sauce! If you haven’t gotten it you’re missing out! Always happy! People on the phone are always helpful!
m phillips
Jun 15,2025
I had a great experience at Al's Pizza! First and foremost the pizza was excellent!! Tom Martin, the new owner, was at the restaurant and was talking to all of the guests. It was like he knew everyone, and there were many people dining in that night. The main attraction, the pizza pie, was perfect - we got our two favorite types and both pies were perfect. The deluxe was perfectly baked with fresh ingredients, perfect amount of cheese, and the sauce had just the right amount of Italian seasoning with a rich tomato flavor. The BLT is my favorite pizza and it was delicious - if you like a great BLT sandwich you can't go wrong with a BLT from Al's Pizza. Now the service did not disappoint us - the waitress was great! As I mentioned the owner was greeting and talking to the guests, and the waitresses were quick and friendly with each of the guests. She was quick, personable, and she checked back several times to make sure we were satisfied. I would give this experience more than 5 stars if I could and will go back again soon! Please stop by Al's Pizza and try the deluxe or BLT it will not disappoint!
Beat-in Buzzard
May 16,2025
When I got word, that Al had closed down in Troy, I told the wife that since they no longer are here in Troy, we will just drive up to Sidney and visit Al's at his location there. Glad we did. I really enjoy your pizza and spaghetti and the entire menu. The garlic bread sticks were exceptional as well, do not shut this one down Al, for small businessmen sake we need you to stay around for a long time. Maybe Trump will give small guys a break for once to keep the American dream alive instead of just giving loans to Mideastern folk.
Heidi Bundy
May 10,2025
The waitress was so nice and friendly. The pizza was amazing . We had the buffet and got to pick our own pizza since we was the only one there and the taco, BLT, BBQ chicken was amazing. The kids loved it as well. The Peanut Butter Smores pizza was literally the best dessert pizza I ever had. You gotta try it!
James Davis
May 6,2025
Love this place over every other food in town. hell lve never had a single complaint. Favorite pizza place in the entire Dayton area hands down. Great job to the staff and the owner
Stevesquaredink
Apr 8,2025
Great pizza with a lunch buffet what else could a group of guys want if you haven't yet better make this a stop and give it a try
Jennifer Hyvarinen
Apr 3,2025
Ate lunch there today after church and there was 1 lady working by herself taking care of everyone there eating and she was out on the floor taking dirty dishes off tables, bringing more pizzas out to the buffet table in dining room, refilling drinks and cashing people out. She did a phenomenal job and the food was hot and delicious no complaints from me
Norman & Melissa May
Mar 21,2025
Ordered to go. Everything meet expectations along with friendly service!
Reviews For Al's Pizza